Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
[00:00:06] Hello listeners to TimeTable London. I'm your host, Tam MacDonald, on my talk this time with Jeff Rowell, our co-host, feeling a little bit under the weather and we're looking forward to welcoming him back soon. Anyway, I'm sitting in the beautiful Fox and Anchor in Smithfield, one of many Smithfield pubs recommended for us by our guest today. Conservationist, urban planner, author, and he tells us bassoon player, Alec Forshaw. Alec, welcome to Timetable London.
[00:00:36] Well, it's great to be here. Now, you've written a book about Smithfield, I understand, and I'm told we'll be talking about that. I've been given my usual menu of topics by our esteemed producer, Chris Winn. I'm glad you can join us today in Jeff's absence, Chris. Pleasure. But no wonder that you know so many of the pubs around here, after all, given your architectural interests. So what can you tell us about the Fox and Anchor rather than me tell the listeners? OK, well, there's been a pub here for a very long time, going back to medieval times.
[00:01:05] But this particular building is a rebuild built in the 1890s. And what's particularly nice about it or unusual about it is it's an Art Nouveau style of architecture, which is quite rare in London. And on the outside, wonderful tile work and faience work, very decorated.
[00:01:27] Inside, we've got these lovely wooden booths with stained glass partitions with all the sort of Art Nouveau tricks of hearts and irregular shapes. It's a beautiful old place. It's now a listed building. What listing would that be? It's listed grade two. Right. And upstairs is now a boutique hotel.
[00:01:54] I used to work as conservation officer in Islington for many years. And there was a time when this pub was very run down and there were sort of concerns about what was going to happen to it. It used to be one of the pubs that sold Smithfield breakfasts.
[00:02:12] In other words, it opened at sort of five o'clock in the morning and had a license to do that and would serve drinks to the market porters and serve these traditional breakfasts, which were very hearty, I think. Anyway, those sort of times were changing a bit. And it was bought by somebody who sort of revamped it and decided to make a little boutique hotel upstairs.
[00:02:40] Now, interestingly, they do these breakfasts again now, but probably mainly for the guests upstairs rather than the market porters. Are these the ones marketed as big boy breakfasts? I think so. Yeah, that's right. That's a marketing term. If you're not a big boy already, you'll become a big boy if you eat too many of them. A lot of the pubs around here used to open early in the morning. I mean, there are about a dozen.
[00:03:03] The market, in its sort of heyday, employed about 2,000 men working at night. And, you know, it's thirsty work. Humping meat around, unloading it from the lorries and loading it back onto the butcher's carts and vans and whatever. Are there any pubs that still open early, do you think? The Hope, at the bottom of Calcross Street, still opens early.
[00:03:33] But that's about it. I mean, it's interesting how the pubs have reinvented themselves, I suppose. Yeah. Smithfield is now a destination. People come to Smithfield just because it's a great place to have a drink. So how far back in time would we go to get to a point where people were starting to talk about Smithfield as if its days were numbered? Well, I got involved with Smithfield in 1976. That's 50 years ago.
[00:04:03] I'd recently joined Islington Council as a baby town planner. And I was put onto this project, which was called the Smithfield Plan. So the background to that was that the Greater London Council produced its London Plan in 1970. And part of that plan was to move all the wholesale food markets out of central London.
[00:04:30] And the first to go, of course, was Covent Garden, which moved to Nine Elms. And then all the others were scheduled to go as well, including Smithfield. Billingsgate moved, as you know. And Smithfield was, you know, it was sort of unsuitable to have these wholesale markets in the middle of London. Well, in Islington, we were very concerned about that.
[00:04:52] Even though the market is within a city and is owned and run by the city, most of the people who worked in the market lived in Islington. And it was not only the market, but at that time, most of the surrounding streets were full of meat related businesses.
[00:05:13] So there were bacon curers, sausage makers, people catering businesses, people making meals for airlines, all sorts of things. And that was employing another 2,000 people. So there were about 4,000 people dependent on the market. And if the market moved to wherever, what was going to happen to those people and those Islington residents? So that's why we were involved.
[00:05:41] And Islington, the City of London, amazingly, given their political differences, worked jointly on the Smithfield plan to save the market and keep it where it was. And that became then wrapped up in requirements from the EU to modernize the market and bring it up to hygiene standards and whatever. And that did eventually happen.
[00:06:10] The city dipped into their pockets and paid for all that. But the area was changing. The market was changing largely because of supermarkets. Supermarkets were not buying their meat at Smithfield Market. They had their own supply, as they still do today. They buy directly from abattoirs and farmers and whatever. So the amount of trade going through Smithfield was shrinking.
[00:06:40] And during the 1980s, most of the related industries, like bacon curers, disappeared. And the side streets became like a ghost town. It's hard to believe that now. But there was... I've got memories of that, very strong memories. It was just full of empty properties. So who was curing all the bacon if it wasn't being cured here? Well, I guess it was... Perhaps it was Denmark was cleaning up on all this stuff.
[00:07:09] And we were importing Danish bacon and whatever. Or it was being moved to new, modern industrial plants outside London. Right. I mean, a lot of the buildings where these works were going on were not particularly suitable. It was difficult to get big lorries into the narrow streets. All that sort of stuff. So you can sort of see why it was happening.
[00:07:35] And then we sort of developed the Smithfield plan into a rather wider planning exercise where we... Well, first of all, we wanted to conserve the historic fabric because very little of it was protected. Yeah. So part of that process, I managed to get the Islington side relisted. That's when this pub got listed. Actually, in 1994, it got listed. And they still charge you for the beer when you come in.
[00:08:04] So are we in Islington in this pub? We are in Islington. So the boundary must be just outside of the pub, is it? No, the boundary is the main bit of Charterhouse Street, which then becomes Carthusian Street. That straight line is now the boundary. It used to wiggle around. I mean, it's interesting, when Charterhouse Street was laid out by the Victorians in the 1860s, when the meat market was built, they didn't actually change the ancient medieval boundaries,
[00:08:33] which wriggled around, and they were eventually changed. Actually, again, in 1994, things were straightened out. Just a question, going back a few minutes, when you mentioned that there were all these industries and small businesses that were peripherally but still substantially dependent upon meat, was that not similarly true for other food industries like fish and Covent Garden and so on? Didn't they have similar sort of sub-industries? Less so.
[00:09:00] I mean, I think with fruit and veg and flowers, there's probably less processing of that. Yeah. And they just all moved out to Nine Elms. With the fish trade at Billingsgate, there were some premises sort of off Lower Thames Street, which were used by the market. Yeah. In fact, you know, when the market closed and moved in 1983,
[00:09:27] the smell of fish lingered on in the cobbles for several years. It really was quite extraordinary how ingrained all that fish oil had become into the fabric of the streets. Oh my gosh, who'd have sunk that, eh? Yeah. It's gone now, of course. They discovered the Roman baths underneath by then. No, they hadn't, no. The big worry at the time was that when they turned the fridges off underneath the market,
[00:09:56] that the whole thing would collapse because they thought, you know, when everything melted, then the whole thing would just subside. But of course, James Bunning, who designed that market, had built it fabulously in the 1850s. So it didn't collapse and it's still there. It's a beautiful building. A beautiful building. Yeah. So how long were these, well, Billingsgate and Smithfield, how long were they sort of in their pomp
[00:10:20] and pretty much as they seemed to be defined, operating in the way that they did before they had to wind down? Well, Smithfield Market, I mean, its heyday probably was the 1920s and 30s. Mm-hmm. That's when it had fully expanded. The coal stores, which had been built to bring all the imported meat from New Zealand, South Africa, Argentina,
[00:10:50] were still coming into the London docks and then being stored in these mighty coal stores. There's one just along here. You can see the facade of it. It's a rather grand building being converted into offices. But there were about a dozen of these huge coal stores where these frozen carcasses would be kept and then they'd be released onto the market when the price was at its best. So what did they do before they had refrigerators?
[00:11:19] Well, everything had to be fresh. So the turnover had to be very quick. Yes, it did. It did. And that was one of the brilliant things about Horace Jones's design of the meat market buildings, the first one 1868 and then the poultry market a few years later and the general market at the western end, is that they were all naturally ventilated. So you had air coming through. Yeah. And of course the market operated at night when it was cool. Cool, yeah. Yeah.
[00:11:49] So, and also that made sense for the butchers who would arrive very early in the morning, buy their stuff and take it back to their shop for the day so it's fresh in their shop. And they'd do that every day. Wow. So all that produce, I suppose, walking down the hollow way or hollowing out the hollow way. The hollow way. Yeah, it was for... Well, it was a drover's road. Yeah. Driving the cattle.
[00:12:15] I mean, that's going back to the livestock market which preceded the dead meat market. So Smithfield, I mean, so let's wind the clock back a thousand years. There's the smooth field which was outside the city walls. Well-drained, high bit of land with the Fleet River Valley on one side
[00:12:42] and Moorgate sort of swamp to the east. So Smithfield, the smooth field, was a good bit of land to do things for which there was no, not enough space within the city. And one of those was a cattle market or a livestock market. That's a great little anecdote to illustrate the truth about geography creates history. Oh, of course it does. Oh, absolutely. And that's, of course, why it's such a privilege to drive your cattle across London Bridge or whichever bridge it was.
[00:13:09] They were on their way from the south up to Smithfield, weren't they? Yeah, cattle, livestock, was driven from far and wide. We're not just talking about the home counties, but cattle was driven from Scotland, even from the islands. The cattle would swim across some sky or the mull to the mainland. And then the journey would be months.
[00:13:35] These cattle would, the journey was horrendously hard. And of course, they'd have to be fed on the way and grazed. And Britain was full of these drovers roads, which often bypassed towns and villages for very good reasons. Probably these reasons, yeah. And the Holloway Road and Archway Road is one of those, bypassing Highgate, Highgate Village. And the last leg.
[00:14:05] So that was a huge, huge industry. And there was increasing pressure as London expanded and the livestock market expanded to feed a million mounds or whatever it had become by the late 18th century. The centre of this growing metropolis was increasingly unsuitable to have a livestock market because the livestock were coming in through all these new suburbs and people didn't want that.
[00:14:35] So pressure mounted to move the livestock market. The City of London, who owned it, got all the rents and tolls. They resisted it ferociously. In fact, it required an Act of Parliament in 1849 to make the market close. And it moved in 1855 to a new location, quite near King's Cross, north of King's Cross, the Caledonian market.
[00:15:06] Oh, of course. Here we go. But of course, what had happened by then is that the railways had arrived. So what was already happening is that the drover's life had gone. Instead of driving these animals, you'd put them on a train. Yeah. And, you know, they could have a much quicker journey, even from Scotland, down to the new livestock market.
[00:15:30] But then people thought, well, why put the animal on the train when we could just put the carcass on the train? We'll kill the animal. We'll have an abattoir actually near a railway sidings. Kill the animal, put the carcass on the train and bring that down. And that's when the city decided, because what arrived in Smithfield was the Metropolitan Line. Right.
[00:15:57] The Metropolitan Railway, which terminated in 1863 at Farringdon. Uh-huh. The purpose of that line was to link up all the other railway termini, which had been built by separate railway companies. So you had Paddington, Marylebone, Euston, King's Cross and Pancras. So it links all those up and down to Liverpool Street as well.
[00:16:25] And so the perfect place to build a dead meat market would be on top of the Metropolitan Line, which was in cut and cover. Uh-huh. Yeah. So that's how Smithfield Market got built in 1868. I didn't realise it was as recent as that. Yeah. Yeah. So that's... Tough on the old cows all that time, wasn't it? Swimming across from the sky all that way to get knocked on the head. Yeah, absolutely.
[00:16:54] And then after a little while they're saying, well, at least we're giving you a train ride before the end now. We're not making you walk the whole way. It was like the Wild West. Well, indeed. Yeah. So can we go back just a little bit to the... Well, a little bit. Was there something happening here in Roman times? No. Because it's outside the walls. It's outside the walls. I think all they did round here was chuck their rubbish. There's very little Roman stuff being found here.
[00:17:24] And it didn't really get used until the sort of Normans turned up. The Saxons didn't use it much. And there's a very small population in sort of... Before the Norman conquest, I think. And of course, this smooth field also then attracted...
[00:17:53] Well, not only the livestock market, but it attracted three very important religious orders who wanted to have monasteries or priors. So the first of those was the Prior of St Bartholomew, which was founded in 1123. So, you know, that's pretty soon after 1066, isn't it? And then just a few years after that, the Knights of St John, just up the road.
[00:18:22] And then the third great one was the Charter House. But that was two centuries later. 1376, that was founded. But those monasteries, you know, they needed big sites. And so Smithville was perfect for that. And then the other big use of the space... Well, two other uses.
[00:18:53] One was Bartholomew Fair. Oh, yeah. Now, that started originally as a commercial cloth fair, which the monks in St Bartholomew started up on their land. And this was really a trade fair for cloth merchants who came from all over Europe to sort of sell their stuff and buy their stuff. In medieval times, England was a great producer of wool.
[00:19:22] Norfolk and Suffolk were famous for their wool. The Cotswolds. Cotswolds too, yes. And all these great churches that were built. And so that trade fair carried on. But it diversified into also a fun fair and became known as Bartholomew Fair. And that carried on long after all that cloth trading had sort of disappeared, really,
[00:19:50] right through into the 19th century. And, of course, Johnson's play, Ben Johnson's play, Bartholomew Fair. Yes, so there's the program there. It became a completely riotous, out of control. Yeah. And again, the Victorians took a dislike to it and they suppressed that. Again, in 1855, when the livestock market was closed, they also closed Bartholomew Fair. Yeah. While we're at it, let's get those guys out of there too. They cleaned the place up, basically. Well, yes.
[00:20:19] In every way. And then the other really unpleasant use of Smithfield was for public executions. The most famous early one was William Wallace. And there's a memorial to him. Oh, is there? On the north wall of St. Bartholomew's Hospital. Oh, right. Which is still something of a shrine for Scottish nationalists. There's often flowers and thistles and stuff placed on it. I can imagine, yes. It would be, yes. So I think that was 1302 or something.
[00:20:49] He was pretty brutally dismembered and put to death. Yes, they didn't do it nicely, did they? They didn't. No. And then the next sort of famous one is Wat Tyler and the Peasants' Revolt. Is this where Wat Tyler was killed? It is. It is. So the story was that they obviously went around ransacking places like Somerset House on the river.
[00:21:15] And they ransacked the priory of St. John's. Oh, right. Burnt that down. And then they moved down to Smithfield because it was a big space. And there was a confrontation then with Richard II and his sort of soldiers. And there was a scuffle and Tyler was wounded in that scuffle.
[00:21:39] And he went into the priory church of St. Bartoneroe where he should have had sanctuary. Oh, yes. The king's soldiers just went in, dragged him out and they cut his head off. Did they? I didn't realise they'd actually done that. Yeah. And that dispersed the mob, basically. That was the end of it. That was the end of it. Yeah. And again, there's a memorial to that. Oh, is there?
[00:22:08] Put up quite recently. And it's rather good. The sculptor Emily Hoffman. Oh, yes. Yes, I know her. It's rather beautiful. And it's on the same wall of the north wall of the hospital.
[00:22:25] And then the main glut of the Smithfield martyrs was the Tudor times with the succession of Protestant, Catholic, Protestant, Catholic, you know, taking their turns. Just the heretics being burnt. I mean, there is a story that Queen Mary sat in the gatehouse of the church to watch. Do you think that's true? I doubt it. Yeah. I doubt it.
[00:22:56] Makes a good story. I think a lot of public went along and watched. Yes. Even more recently, a monument has been put up to Anne Askew. She was put to death in 1546. And she was a poet and sort of free thinker.
[00:23:16] And that has been put into the ground, into a paving stone, right on the main entrance to the West Gateway into the churchyard. And, again, Emily Huffman was done the. What was her story? Well, she was a Protestant, but she was put to death by Protestants.
[00:23:40] So it's even more, you know, she didn't comply with their right form of Protestantism. So, I mean, they were all mad. But whenever workmen dig up paving stones around there, you don't have to go very far down to hit these thick layers of black ash from all the fires. Really? Yeah. Gosh, it's that much. Well, they burnt a lot of wood, of course. Yes, yes.
[00:24:11] To get the whole thing burning. To get the whole thing burning. And I think quite frequently, the victims, they were kind people, would put gunpowder into their clothing so that when they're caught for it, they'd be blown up and have a quick death. My gosh, I thought I'd heard all that sort of stuff, but I hadn't heard that story. Who would put the gunpowder in? Their friends. The people themselves.
[00:24:36] Well, yes, you know, the people themselves or friends would help them get hold of it. I mean, because often they would have been in prison beforehand, so it would have been quite tricky. Or maybe even a kind executioner. Right. Yeah. And didn't they burn some of them in burning oil? Yeah, all sorts of nasty stuff. All sorts of nasty stuff. So that carried on right through the whole of the 16th century.
[00:25:07] Until Tyburn took over? Yes, Tyburn took over. And that became a great day out, didn't it? Yes. Tyburn was way out in the countryside along the Oxford Road. Yeah. And I guess all those sort of pubs along the way where the prisoner would be offered a drink or whatever. And depending on the popularity or unpopularity of the victim, they'd be, you know, pelted with manure or flowers. Yeah.
[00:25:37] Offered drinks or whatever. Well, there's a whole psychology to be written there. I guess it has been written about public executions and how they become entertainment. It's quite relevant at the moment. Particularly timely, I was going to say. Yeah, yeah. But so the Smithfield Martyrs, and apologies if you covered this ground, but the Smithfield Martyrs were whom? They were, well, regarded as heretics. So they were not... So it was a religious thing. It was a religious thing, entirely. Yeah.
[00:26:03] So it was people who were not conforming with the current regime. Right. And in turns, you know, we had Henry VIII. You then had Queen, well, Edward VI, Queen Mary, who was obviously Catholic, and then Queen Elizabeth, who reverted to Protestantism. So it was... Did Henry VIII have people? He did. Really? Yeah. Ann Askey was... Was under him. Under him, yes. Yeah. Well, it started quite early.
[00:26:33] It seemed normalised. Maybe that's one of Elizabeth's great achievements, that she seemed to put the damper on that, didn't she? Well, no, not really. No? No, that carried on quite a long time into her reign. Really? Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it wouldn't have been her particularly. It was her... All the sort of men of her court. Well, that's it, yeah. And, you know, there was some pretty... Walsingham and all these sort of people.
[00:26:57] And just as I was saying that, I was remembering the gunpowder plot, which there wasn't any shortage of bloodletting and... No. And, of course, that was a religious thing. You know, they were Catholics trying to blow up the process. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That's it. Religion's got a lot to answer for. They were the last to be hung, drawn and quartered, weren't they? Probably. Yeah. Somebody put a stop to that. But then the...
[00:27:22] When Tyburn was suppressed as an execution place, the executions, then public executions moved to Newgate. And there were public executions there. And there's lots of prints and illustrations of all that. And great, you know, stands have been put up in the street. This is pretty much where the Old Bailey is today. And there's a pub there still today called the Magpie and Stump.
[00:27:53] That's escaped me. Yeah, Magpie and Stump. That's escaped me too. It's rather unprepossessing. It's in the sort of bottom of a modern office block. Oh, right. It's an ancient site of a pub and a rather wonderful name. And there are wonderful illustrations of that when it was a sort of multi-storied inn with all these people hanging out of the windows, you know, looking at the executions that's going on in the street. So how would you explain then the shift over the centuries from this public execution,
[00:28:21] people hanging out of windows and all this ghastly stuff, to the time when you get to Arthur Pierpoint and the executions of the 19th century, 20th century? Well, the last public execution, I think, is in the 1860s. Michael Barrett, who was, I think might have been Irish, there was a thing called the Fenian Outrage in the 1860s, when various Irish prisoners who were being held up in Clerkenwell in the... The Hensonville?
[00:28:51] No, in the House of Detention. Oh. Which was still going strong then. Just up the road, just north of Clerkenwell Green. The House of Detention, where people were held on remand. So Michael Barrett and the accomplices blew up a section of the wall to get these prisoners out. And anyway, they were caught and put to death. And so that was the last public execution.
[00:29:20] But then executions after that carried on inside Newgate. And there was the execution block within the prison. And that carried on there until 1902, when Newgate was pulled out. And then executions carried on in prisons. So there were executions carried out at Pentonville. So there are some whose names should not be smirched, the Timetable London podcast.
[00:29:50] But we know who we're talking about when we say that some people would regard this shift in history as a softening of society. Back in the days when men were men and we'd all go out and we'd watch a good public hanging. Or like the Cray story in the pub. I came here for a proper shootout. You know, when men were men. Well, the British Parliament abolished the death sentence. It's quite a long time ago. It's when did they abolish it? I think it was in the 1960s, wasn't it? I think it was, yes. It's when those sort of things got abolished. Because there'd been some...
[00:30:20] The 1960s counts as a long time ago? Well, quite a long time ago. It's quite a long time ago. It's history to most people. It is. Not necessarily to us, but to most people. Yeah, only 60 years ago. Hi, this is Tim MacDonald, your host. If you're enjoying Timetable London, then please tell your friends about us by sending them a link to the show, giving us a mention on social media, or even by, or especially by, chatting about us in the pub.
[00:30:50] Timetable London, for everything you love about the world's greatest city. Time being short on us and the hinterland being rich, can we shift to something else? I'd be really interested in... I assume that our brief introduction to you was pretty much accurate in terms of your key areas of interest. So, urban planner is a big thing in the life of Forshaw. Most of my life. So, when you look back over the history that we're describing, going back literally centuries,
[00:31:19] when did urban planning become a thing to the extent that what seems like a fairly higgledy-piggledy development of London being driven by what the god-botherers wanted here and what the meat merchants wanted here and so on? Goes back further than you think. Yeah, I mean, there have been efforts by authorities to improve London for a long, long time.
[00:31:41] After the Great Fire in 1666, John Evelyn and Christopher Wren drew up very grand plans for rebuilding the city in a very geometric way with wide boulevards, big piazzas and plazas. I mean, didn't come to much, but there were bits of improvements carried out.
[00:32:07] And then, of course, you have Nash and the building of Regent Street, the laying out of Regent's Park with its villas around it. You know, that's sort of urban planning on a very grand scale. Yeah, sure. And the Victorians were incredible improvers of the city. The works they did around Smithfield are monumental. Right.
[00:32:34] I mean, we think... Well, the viaduct and something. Well, the Hoban viaduct is a huge, huge undertaking. Yeah. The railways, the building of roads like Rosebury Avenue and Shaftesbury Avenue, Queen Victoria Street, the embankment, all the works that Basilgette did, the narrowing of the Thames, the rebuilding of the bridges. Yeah.
[00:33:03] I mean, amazing works that they did. This is before any sort of town and country planning act. So people... So when was the first town and country planning act? 1947. Right. And the timing pretty much explains itself, doesn't it? Yeah. Yeah. And that was... Well, there were new towns set up to sort of solve the crisis in London
[00:33:29] and also not to have too many eggs in one basket, this nuclear war as a possibility. So how was the Victorian planning done? It was a sort of ad hoc basis. Something needs to be done here. No. Well, there was the Metropolitan Board of Works, who were big commissioners. And they had a... Well, great people on the board and they commissioned big bits of work. And there were politicians involved with that.
[00:33:56] People like Lord Rosebury and Shaftesbury. Yeah. And then it was... So it wasn't just ad hoc with landowners doing it, the greater states. It was a more public body than that. And the Metropolitan Board of Works sort of morphed into the London County Council. For Thames. And the Metropolitan Water Board sort of morphed eventually into Thames Water. Oh, crikey.
[00:34:26] So you had these... There is a development, eh? We went a little bit backwards there. You got these big... Well, they were a public body, Thames Water originally. Did they do the wonderful water troughs and things? Sorry? Did they do the wonderful water troughs and things? Well, there was the Metropolitan Drinking Fountain Organisation, which put in troughs for animals and also drinking fountains for people. Which they used to put outside pubs, didn't they?
[00:34:56] Some of them. I think one of the first ones is on the corner of Newgate Street and Giltzburg Street. Where St. Sepulchre's Church is. Oh. That's supposed to be the first public drinking fountain in London. It's a rather beautiful... Is that next to the Viaduct Pub? It is. On top of the hill there. Yes, opposite it. Yes. And it's a lovely marble thing. And then where the water comes out of it. I don't think it does want to. It should be restored. It should be.
[00:35:26] Because it's a real monument. It is. I think the Victorians and Ed Warrens are very unsentimental. Yes. Yes. Amazing stuff that they pulled down, which had it survived. I mean, some wonderful photographs taken before the First World War of some of the streets in Smithfield when they still had these amazing medieval buildings.
[00:35:48] Because Smithfield, because of the walls that still stood in 1666, the walls protected Smithfield from the fire. Oh, right. So Smithfield retained a lot of pre-fire buildings. But then the Victorians got rid of most of them. But Cloth Fair is lovely, isn't it? It has still got... Cloth Fair's still got some of the old buildings. It has got one of them. Which is where... Simon lived, of course. Who was the great... Yes. There's a plaque up to him. Yes, there is.
[00:36:18] And that's opposite what's supposed to be the oldest house in the city of London. Is that right? It is. It's 1614. It's supposed to have been built. Lovely house. It is lovely. Got an interesting story. It was lived in after the war. Or maybe before the war, actually. I think from the 1930s.
[00:36:36] It's by two architects, Celie and Padgett, who were a pair in real life and in practice. And they lived there. They restored the house. And they had their practice there. And they did a lot of restoration work after the war. So the charter house was very badly damaged in the war.
[00:37:05] And they did the restorations there. Similarly, St John's Square. They did a lot of the rebuilding there. And they were given the austerity of the time and the shortage of materials. They were pretty good. And they were there until the late 1960s. Really? Yeah. Interestingly, they had on the top floor, they had a bathroom with two baths in it.
[00:37:32] So at the end of the day, they could both have a bath in the same room and discuss how business had gone during the day. Have you ever heard of that, Chris? I hadn't heard that one. I've heard lots of stories about that house, but I hadn't heard that one. You'll have to rush straight home and see if that would go down well. I'll have a separate bathroom. Apparently, the windows downstairs have a lot of 60s and 70s Labour politicians. That's right. Names, scratch them. Why was that?
[00:38:00] Well, Celia and Patrick were very well connected. And all sorts of people, Princess Margaret and all sorts of people visited there. And one of the things that they entertained a lot, I think. And, you know, they had a live-in housekeeper and a live-in chef and all this sort of stuff. And one thing they asked their guests to do was etch their name in the windows. And they did. And they're all still there.
[00:38:29] And the current owner, a very nice man called Matthew Bell, who's a city councillor as well. And he lives there. And he still encourages that tradition. Wonderful. Oh, wow. Good. That's a wonderful tradition. But, yeah, Cloth Fair is a lovely little street. It's a super little street. I hadn't really spotted Cloth Fair. There's a very nice pub along there called the Hand and Shears, which, of course, is a reminder of the old cloth trade. Yes.
[00:38:59] And when I first knew Smithfield in the 1970s, there was a cloth merchant still there in one of the shops, Mitchell and Inman. And their speciality was the green bays, the snooker tables. Oh, right. Isn't that extraordinary? Talk about niche, eh? Yeah. Very niche, yeah. Yeah. There were also still at that time a few businesses whose trade dated back to the livestock market.
[00:39:27] So there was a button maker, button dealer. Now, buttons used to be made out of horns and hooves from animals. And there was a tennis racket gut dealer. And before nylon and all that stuff, it used to be animal gut. And they'd been there since the early 19th century. Oh, wow. They're all long gone now. They all disappeared. Oh, what a shame.
[00:39:57] Yeah. Was Smithfield bombed in the war? Not as badly as much of the city, of course. But there was bomb damage. The worst incident was the last V2 rocket to land on London. This is in sort of mid-March 1945. Landed near the junction of Charterhouse Street and Farringdon Road. Oh. Oh.
[00:40:27] And it killed about 170 people. Really? Yeah. So there were still a lot of people in the area at that time? It's tragic, really. It's tragic, really, because the market was closed during the war because they thought too many people in one place can't have that. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But what happened is that sort of illegal stuff happened. And what was going on, apparently, was rabbits were being sold.
[00:40:55] You know, dead rabbits. Yes. And there were a whole lot of, you know, housewives there trying to buy this stuff. And this bomb landed on them. It was a terrible explosion. Apparently, one of the victims was somebody walking across Blackfriars Bridge, which is quite a long way away. And they were killed by part of a railway sleeper that had been thrown up from the tunnels
[00:41:24] below and hit them on Blackfriars Bridge. Gosh. Isn't that extraordinary? Not an awful lot of people know that, I would bear faith. That corner has been quite recently redeveloped, part of the Crossrail Elizabeth Line Station enabling works. There's a new building there. And on the corner there, there's a memorial in the ground to that meter. Really? That locket. Which is a good thing.
[00:41:53] Because there used to be a tunnel under here, didn't there? A Snow Hill Tunnel. The Snow Hill Tunnel was still there. That was abandoned and now used by Thameslink. That's right. Yeah. Yes. Comes into Farrington. That was an important thing. I mean, the construction of Thameslink and Crossrail, or the Elizabeth Line, means that Farrington Station is extremely well connected now.
[00:42:22] It's certainly very important, isn't it? It's a hub. A hub of London. Absolutely. You can get, so some people say, to sort of all six London airports, if you can name them, in half an hour. It's incredibly well connected, which bodes very well for the museum when it opens in about six weeks' time. So what do you think about the museum and the development? I think it's great. I mean, I was heavily involved.
[00:42:50] I retired from Islington in 2007, having done 35 years in government, local government. But I continued to remain involved in various sort of planning call celebs. And one of those issues was the future of the Western market buildings. Yeah. Because the meat market had shrunk and the buildings at the Western end had become abandoned by the city corporation.
[00:43:18] And they had ambitious plans to pull them down and build offices. And I got involved in the campaign to stop that. And there was a public inquiry in 2014, which was fronted up by SAVE and the Victorian Society. Oh, yes. And I was the planning witness and conservation witness. And we won that appeal.
[00:43:48] The Secretary of State and the planning inspector supported us. But at that time, well, we didn't really have an alternative scheme. We had an idea that perhaps it could become a sort of food market, a bit like Covent Garden or Borough Market or Spitalfields, you know, these sort of places. But, you know, it wasn't a really great plan.
[00:44:15] But then it just shows you these things are worth fighting because you don't know what the outcome is going to be. So about two years later, the newish director of the what was then called the Museum of London on its site at the end of London Wall was getting increasingly fed up with the constraints of that museum. True. Impossible to extend. Quite difficult for the public to find. Yes, yes. I mean, quite nice when you got in it.
[00:44:43] But she basically said, why don't we move to the Western Market buildings? And so that's when it started. Is this Sharon Amos? Sharon, yes. So that was her idea to come out. Well, her and her. But yeah. Yeah. And there was the opportunity. So had those offices been built, that opportunity wouldn't have arisen. Right.
[00:45:08] Because this was probably the best collection of Victorian buildings left in London, wasn't it? Certainly of market buildings. I mean, it's probably the best collection of market buildings in Europe. Yeah. I mean, it's an amazing run of buildings, isn't it? Absolutely. The poultry market was burnt down in a terrible fire in the late 1950s and rebuilt 1962 in a
[00:45:34] modern, but actually a spectacular building, which the museum are going to occupy. But the general market building beyond that is a wonderful Victorian market building. With this fabulous dome supported by these Phoenix columns. Yes. Amazing thing. Absolutely glorious. I mean, Londoners, visitors to London are going to love this place. Absolutely. And of course, there's so much below ground. Yeah.
[00:46:03] That's the fantastic thing about Smithfield is it's a bit like an iceberg, really. There's more below ground than above ground. Well, there. Shout out to our colleague, Jeff Rowell. Whenever we have one of these discussions with one of our guests, he'll always put in a bug for London below ground. Underground, yeah. That's right. And what we can do with that. One of the nice features, you may know this, we were talking about the Snow Hill Tunnel. Oh, yes. Paris, the Thames League. Well, that runs through the museum.
[00:46:31] And there's going to be glass walls so that from the train you can see the museum. And from the museum you can see the trains. Oh, how wonderful. Yeah. That's a unique selling point of the museum. How often do we find that in the world? Is that pretty much a unique... It is. It is a unique selling point. Yeah. Use the word. I wanted to ask you, Alec, how would you characterize the general social sensitivity to the principles of conservation in moving forward with history and the buildings that
[00:47:00] have created that history? We talked earlier about the Victorians being quite spectacularly unsentimental and indeed not very superstitious. How do we compare these days? Are we a little bit more attuned? Much more. Much, much more. And of course it all quite happily, I think, coincides now with the green agenda. Reusing buildings. There's this word that's used now called retrofit, which is repurposing existing buildings.
[00:47:30] And of course, if you look at some of the really ancient buildings, like say St. John's Gate. Yes. They've been retrofitted many, many times. It's a long time since it was a monastery. And the different uses that building has gone through is extraordinary. And there's no reason why every building can't do that. No kidding. We have to reuse existing buildings, even if they are, I would argue, not particularly historic.
[00:47:59] But we can't be pulling stuff down and putting up new stuff. We've got to get out of that because it just destroys the world. That's a great philosophical couldundrum, isn't it? I mean, what actually constitutes authentic historical buildings? When you're trying to retrofit, there's always going to be somebody who says, well, you think that's authentic, but it's not authentic. Well, if it's there, try and keep it. Try and reuse the fabric that's there.
[00:48:24] Because whatever that fabric is, even if it's 1950s or 1970s, that fabric, by being there, has got what I would call embodied energy. That's the energy from the materials that it's been made of, the effort that's gone into making it, the effort that's gone into actually putting it in that place. Keep it there if you can.
[00:48:51] Were you a member of SPAB, Society for Protection of Ancient Buildings? Because I guess it started by William Morris, wasn't it? It was, yes. Do you think that was the SPAB? Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings. But yes, they were founded by William Morris. And of course, he was appalled by what quite a lot of his Victorian brethren were doing,
[00:49:21] pulling down these ancient buildings. And he had various campaigns, many of which initially he lost. I mean, one of the great campaigns he lost was St. Albans Abbey or Cathedral. The West Front, the great medieval West Front of that, was removed and replaced by a new West Front designed by Gilbert Scott, I think in the 1860s.
[00:49:50] And Morris was appalled by the loss of that medieval fabric. And on the basis of that and various other tragedies who were founded the SPAB. So would you call him the sort of first conservator? The first conservation society. To really... To sort of bring it into the consciousness. Bring other people and set up a society. And sort of on the back of that, the idea of scheduled ancient monuments arose.
[00:50:20] And to begin with, there are very few of those. Things like Stonehenge and the Tower of London. Some fairly obvious candidates. But that's, I suppose, when the idea of actually protecting a bit of fabric arose. And, you know, we've gone from there. So when you were on Islington Council, was that... At that time, were they thinking to conserve buildings?
[00:50:50] Well, the idea of... It was a battle. The 70s and 80s were quite a battle. There were a lot of developers who were wanting to pull these old smokehouses down. And the warehouses and the old coal stores. And we had some big, big battles. One of them was actually called the Danish Bacon site. Which was bought up. This is in Cowcross Street. Oh, yes. North side of Cowcross Street.
[00:51:16] About 40 buildings were bought up by a property developer who wanted to knock the whole lot down and build big office blocks. And we had a big battle. And we designated conservation areas. We got a listing review done. And, yeah, we sort of won, I think. And, you know, the area's been quite well preserved now. It's got its amazing network of medieval streets still.
[00:51:47] Little narrow streets. Yes, it has. Not in a gridiron plan. It's not like the West End where everything's at 90 degrees. It's a funny higgledy-piggledy area. Got little passageways through, little nooks. That's its charm. It's a wonderful area to walk around. For sure. And amazing old street names as well. Like Cowcross Street. Yeah, exactly. Or Cock Lane. Cock Lane, exactly. I wonder what went on there.
[00:52:13] I think it was named after its poultry, I'm sure. I'm sure it was, yes. It also became a red-light district. This is going to seem awfully off the wall. But do you happen to be an Arsenal fan? Not really. But I did live for a while very near the Arsenal Stadium in Holloway. Oh, right. Well, I asked him because the song that's come out, that they've made their club song, North London Forever,
[00:52:41] had me thinking of you when I was hearing it the other day at the football match. And it's really a testimony to the powers of places to define people and their allegiance to place. I mean, the chorus everybody knows is North London Forever. But the verses that go through, if you listen to the lyrics, it's really quite remarkable. Just what a sense they have of the place when a lot of people would think, doesn't sound like much of a place to me, it sounds pretty grotty.
[00:53:08] But people's capacity to invest themselves and their souls in the buildings that they live in. It doesn't matter whether you're living in Lise Palace or... No, I think the majority of people, they may know nothing about listed buildings or even architecture, but they do respond intensely to the locality that they know. For sure. It's everything, really. That is their environment. And they get attached to it.
[00:53:37] And I think it's quite right these days that some quite humble areas architecturally are now being designated as conservation areas. So you can't just pull the whole lot down and give the area a sense of status. There's lots of little villages, aren't there, in London? Yes, it's called the villages. Stoke Newington or somewhere has just become a conservation area. Yeah, it's quite right. Quite right, too. Are you a Londoner? Not originally, no.
[00:54:06] I came from Cambridge. Oh, right. That's what, hence, growing up in Cambridge. Yes, that's right. Yeah. But I moved to London sort of as soon as I could. All my friends had come to London. Right. And, yeah, I've been here ever since. So what's coming up next now? You must have another 17 books in the works. Well, Smithfield rewrite is so on the back of my initial involvement in Smithfield in the 70s.
[00:54:34] I wrote a book which was published in 1980 called Smithfield Past and Present. And that was republished in 1990 when things were still looking pretty bad. And then I did another edition in 2015 when things were really looking pretty good. But that was before we knew that the museum was coming. Right. Before Crossrail. Before COVID.
[00:55:04] Oh, gosh, yes. Which has changed the world as well. Indeed it did. So I've written another edition. Wow. Which is coming out to coincide with the opening of the museum. Museum. The end of November. Coming out the end of November. Oh, we must look out for that. Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. We'll get an invite to the launch. Oh, I do hope so. Oh, how fabulous. So do you update them each time or is it a new book each time? It's pretty much a new book. I've done quite a big rewrite this time.
[00:55:34] I mean, obviously the history doesn't really change. There's new things that I've put in. There's always new stuff to discover. Yeah. Well, same facts, new perspectives. Well, sometimes there's new facts. So, for example, when they were doing the excavations for Crossrail, the archaeologists came across a whole load of bodies that had been buried in the plague pit from the Black Death.
[00:56:05] Crazy. And that was really, really interesting because this is why Charterhouse was founded, the monastery, because there'd been a plague pit in the Black Death, which was 1348. And then a monastery was founded around it. And the assumption of historians had been that the plague was a terrible thing. You had these pits and the bodies were just chucked in. Yeah, yeah.
[00:56:33] And a third of the population died or maybe even half the population in London. What it turned out when they found these bodies is that they were buried in neat rows. Oh, really? Yeah, yeah. They'd been given what looked like a Christian burial. So they weren't just chucked in. Really interesting. And then the sort of medical archaeologists were really interested to see what sort of lives these people had led
[00:57:01] through analysing their bones and all that sort of stuff and who they were. So that sort of thing, new things coming to light always. No kidding. Well, one thing. History doesn't stand for it. You should look out for that book. Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. So timetable listeners can look out for the book. But last question for just a bit of fun. If timetable listeners would like to listen to you play the bassoon, when's your next gig? Well, my next gig is tomorrow. Oh, oh. Just out in Tame outside Oxford. And then on Saturday in Ipswich.
[00:57:29] But I'm playing in London in November. Got a concert in London in November in St. Gabriel's Pimlico on, I think it's Friday the 21st of, no, Friday the 20th of November. St. Gabriel's Pimlico. So there we are. Well, that's recorded there. It is. Very good. So is this with an orchestra? It's with a chamber group. Chamber group. Right. Gosh. Can we find any of your work on YouTube?
[00:57:58] Yes, you almost certainly can. Oh, wow. If you look up either Galliard Trio or Harmony Music. Galliard Trio? I've heard of that. Or Harmony Music is the other group I play with. And you'll find stuff. Right. Well, we'll look that out. Inevitably. Okay. I think we'd all agree that we've been talking so much and enjoying ourselves so much we haven't even got through our pints. So I'm going to have to get the pints in. But thank you, Alec, for joining us. I think this has been fantastic. The only sad bit is that Jeff hasn't been here to enjoy it with us. Because he would have loved it, wouldn't he?
[00:58:27] Well, we'll have four, two, three and four. Well, I'm sure we can. We've barely scratched the surface. Exactly. We're glad. Cheers. Cheers. Thank you, Alec. Thank you. It's been a pleasure. During this very enjoyable podcast on Smithfield, we discussed with Alec the opening of the new London Museum in two of the old market halls on November the 28th. In a few weeks' time, just after the opening, in fact, we will be talking to the museum's
[00:58:55] director, Sharon Amon, about what the new museum will look like and her vision for the future. You won't want to miss that. Sharon Amon, director of the London Museum, coming out December the 30th. And to the future, as ever, Timetable London is looking forward with more than our usual anticipation to our next podcast guest, curator and Hyde director at Dr. Johnson's house in central London.
[00:59:21] No doubt the spirit of the great Cham himself will be listening out for Celine Lupo-McDae. The Old Cheshire Chief, 19 November.

