Ye Olde Cheshire Cheese with Celine Luppo McDaid
TimeTable LondonNovember 19, 2026x
4
54:0149.46 MB

Ye Olde Cheshire Cheese with Celine Luppo McDaid

Down to Ye Olde Cheshire Cheese to meet Celine Luppo McDaid, curator of Dr Johnson's House at 17 Gough Square off Fleet Street. What sort of man was he? Did he frequent the Cheese, his local? Celine tells all......

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

[00:00:00] Hello dear listeners, today we are heading for one of London's oldest pubs, the Olde Cheshire Cheese off Fleet Street, to meet Celine Luppo McDaid, curator of Dr. Johnson's House in Goff Square. Loyal listeners since back in the day may remember that Celine and I recorded a podcast for Cradle of English way back on May Day of 2020.

[00:00:20] We sat in the parlor at Dr. Johnson's house and discussed the various influences that made Fleet Street a magnet for creative energies generally, and of course, most spectacularly, for Dr. Johnson himself. Fast forward to the present, and TimeTable London is interested in one of the creative energies of our own time, charged with keeping the legacy of Dr. Samuel Johnson alive today.

[00:00:50] Hello again listeners of TimeTable London, a podcast crafted by lovers of London for lovers of London. And today we're making a bit of a repeat visit, not just for the podcast crew, but for me. I've been here at the Olde Cheshire Cheese in Fleet Street more than once or twice, or maybe more than 40 or 50 times, all in a very good cause, but no better cause than today. Today we're allowed to reacquaint ourselves with Celine Lupo McDade? Celine Lupo McDade?

[00:01:20] Celine Lupo McDade, yeah. Celine Lupo McDade. Careful listeners to Cradle of English podcast will remember perhaps that Celine and I did a podcast in the drawing room at Dr. Johnson some years ago. Not all that many years ago, but we thought that next time we'd come to this place, if only because the stout is better here than it is at Dr. Johnson's house. So that's for sure.

[00:01:43] Anyway, Celine McDade, very nice to be seeing you again here, especially given what was happening just the other night at your place, because you've got some recent news to impart with all our listeners, given the fact that you're now a two-plaque building. We are very hot off the press, yes, a two-plaque building. And as I was very recently reminded, we are, for probably a brief moment, the only site in the City of London with the oldest and the newest blue plaques, which is really exciting. I like a double superlative.

[00:02:11] So the first one installed 150 years ago to the year for Samuel Johnson to mark 17 Goff Square as his home. But just a few weeks ago, also installed a plaque to Francis Barber to note the fact that that was also his home. A fascinating character. Indeed he is, or indeed he was. Helping us co-host today is Kirstie, who's actually the last time we did a podcast here, Kirstie, you were part of that podcast, weren't you? It was indeed.

[00:02:41] It was the Ghost Society one. The Ghost Society, yeah. Which I shared recently on my socials as it seemed relevant for Halloween. Oh, there you go. Did Dr. Johnson's spirit feature in that at all? Sadly not, I don't think. Or maybe, well, I don't know. I don't know if Dr. Johnson featured. I do know that we were talking about Polly the Parrot, who sits aloft above the bar currently, the famous pub parrot that was here. And I was reading about him again earlier today in preparation for this.

[00:03:11] And apparently there was so much folklore about him, stuff that wasn't necessarily true. Someone said that apparently, I've got to hear it, after Polly died of quite old age, the parrot had a peculiar habit of uttering the words, no, sir, in the exact ponderous manner attributed to Dr. Johnson. So haunting was the pronunciation of these two words that many Americans were led to believe that the parrot really knew the great lexicographer in its youth. And there was a lot of misinformation about how old Polly the Parrot was,

[00:03:41] but definitely was not old enough to have died in, I think, 1926. Oh. And also known Dr. Johnson. Not a 150-year-old parrot. No, absolutely. He did live to an impressive age, but definitely not of that incredible age. Well, certainly not old enough to have been coached by Dr. Johnson to say no in any particular style. No, indeed. No, I think he was more about, I think his favourite phrase was something like, Charlie is the pudding ready. He used to mimic the chop house cooks and the bartenders quite a lot.

[00:04:08] But yes, Paul the Parrot is my favourite little piece of trivia about this particular pub. Yeah. Careful listeners might have picked up that we've been going for three or four minutes and we haven't heard from our other co-host, the esteemed King's College Emeritus, Dr. Jeff Browell, who last time in this pub was quite happy to put the boot in on me for not being there because I was off in my Coswell mansion. Today I'm here and he's in Australia, so yaboo sucks to you, Jeff. That's good. We're missing you terribly.

[00:04:38] Good place to start in the Cheshire Cheese has got to be with this old thing about Dr. Johnson didn't ever come here, there's no evidence about it. Well, yeah, yeah, hot on the tails of Paul the Parrot, having heard, or did she, Johnson utter any words whatsoever within the walls of the old Cheshire Cheese. Well, it's hotly debated amongst Johnson scholars because there is effectively no real evidence

[00:05:02] to say he ever crossed the threshold. And you will get some people being a little bit precious about this, saying never, ever, never would he, never did it occur. When I think, well, that's, I mean, how do you prove a negative is honestly the question. And is it not sensible to think that he probably popped over occasionally, even if it definitely wasn't one of his regular haunts and it wasn't one of the places where he'd hold some of his, you know, debating society evenings.

[00:05:29] But that's not to say, it was his local, it's his closest pub. It's been here even before Dr. Johnson's house itself was built, having been rebuilt in 1666, the pub that is, not Johnson's house. Johnson's house about 20, 30 years later was completed. So I think it's pretty silly to suggest he never came. I think so. And it's so much cheaper back then, probably even now to, to be eating out,

[00:05:53] go for a pint and a pie rather than, you know, shopping around for the ingredients, heating your house to heat it, spending time yourself, employing somebody else to cook for it. Yeah, it was much, much cheaper. You're ready meal for one, really, of ye olde days. So I'm sure he was here. And the fact that that living legend exists, I, you know, as a curator, right. And he was in the pubs as we knew. And he had his quotes about how pubs are fantastic places to be. Exactly. And in fact, listeners who want to test the proposition can do as I did.

[00:06:23] But I was just getting to know you, Celine. And I measured the number of steps between this pub and your house, Dr. Johnson's house. 129 steps. Even a man of his portly girth could manage those steps. Yeah. Easily well, I would have thought. Exactly. On a winter's day, where better to get warmed up? The open fire that still is here today. Exactly. They can have their open fire. Wonderful. So how long have you been at the house now? The views are flying by. But you became curator there in 20? Well, yes. So various iterations.

[00:06:52] I've been there 15 years now. But I've been running it for about 13, 13 and a half now. Yeah. So a long, long time. Longer than I ever thought I would. But now I can't envisage doing anything else. Long enough possibly to have seen or heard a ghost as ghosts are a subject. That is fascinating. I'm sorry. I missed that session. I am wretchedly atheistic and sceptical of such things myself.

[00:07:17] But that does not prohibit me from, you know, taking on the stories and the reactions of lots of other people who genuinely do feel far more spiritually alert than I could ever dream of being. A presence. A presence. Not necessarily a haunting as in a, you know, boo kind of ghost from behind a beam somewhere. But some sort of residual presence. Some sort of spectre. Somebody once mentioned seeing an orb floating up the staircase or something.

[00:07:45] I might have thought it was perhaps an optical illusion. But that's me being sceptical again. But yeah, certainly there are many, many occasions when I'm there alone. Often at night locking up or, you know, finishing off some work or other. And I'll be closing up the house. And my God, it does creak. Now, my rush mind's telling me, don't worry, Celine. It's just the floorboards. It's the, you know, it's the old pipes. We've had the heating on. It's just creaking, blah, blah, blah. Rationalising away.

[00:08:11] But, you know, if you were more susceptible to otherworldly sensations, you might want to scarper. But yes, no, being in an old building alone. It ends along with so much history or story. It's not about ghosts. It's just about that. A sense of space, isn't it? And a sense of history. I mean, it's a real privilege. And it's one that even over the course of 15 years hasn't waned at all. It is, you know, to be a key holder is extraordinary. To have the place to yourself. I know, I was so proud when I got a key.

[00:08:40] It really is something else. Yeah, absolutely. Maybe that's a ghost in sort of a gentler, secular sense. It's not exactly Casper the Friendly, the White Chef and all the rest of that. But just the awe, the respect you feel for what was done in that room makes you think, this is a special moment. Yeah, it raises goosebumps. I've got goosebumps talking about it here right now with you. Whenever you say that, there is absolutely the sense of history, like in the church. Something extraordinary took place here once on these very floorboards and these staircase and these very rooms.

[00:09:10] One of the greatest minds I've ever had the privilege of, can't say getting to know, but, you know, getting to read, getting to understand, trying to get to grips with. It's extraordinary and just to inhabit those same spaces. But for a house like this where, I mean, so he, so all of the work he did was done? For the dictionary, the vast majority was done, yes. So he wasn't born there, he didn't die there, but it was, the decade that he lived there was his most prolific as an author and most significant in being the site of the compilation of the dictionary.

[00:09:39] Even instantly, if he wasn't born here, why did he come here? What inspired him to come here? Well, yes, speaking of great places, it brings us back to the Cheshire Cheese and the literary associations here. And the reason that Cheese has got so many literary associations as a pub is because it's alongside Fleet Street. And the Fleet Street itself, of course, as we well know, is the real birthplace of the printed word. You know, William Caxton, yes, he set up over in that Westminster nearby, but it was the

[00:10:07] city of London that really commercialised it in that very entrepreneurial way that it always has, is and will continue to do, probably. So, yeah, since the year 1500, Wink and DeWord coming here with his printing press. Caxton was really just providing a way station to Westminster before his... Exactly, he's a stepping stone. That's it, he's exactly that. An integral part in the chain that would become the gargantuan machine of the printed word that was Fleet Street, extraordinary.

[00:10:34] So, Johnson, born 100 or so miles north in Litchfield, just north of Birmingham, came down in his 20s having tried a few iterations of work, principally a teacher, fairly miserably at that. He had knowledge, but let's say not the patience. Yes. And yeah, he was really from childhood a writer. He was composing his first poetry by the age of three. So, and I think later, you know, in Latin and stuff as well. So, you know, an extraordinary mind, there was no better place for him than the extraordinary

[00:11:04] Fleet Street. Why was he approached to do the dictionary? Yeah, well, that's, yeah, already you're saying a lot because most people, a lot of my job is myth busting. So it was his idea, he wrote it and then sold it or something. No, it's absolutely going back to the idea of this being a commercial word. It was a commission. He was approached, consortium of publishers along Fleet Street with Robert Doddsley, William Straughan, Longman. But it was Doddsley who, whose brainchild it really was, you know, identifying that gap in the market.

[00:11:34] Again, it's not the first ever English dictionary. That's another myth. Yeah, I was wondering, the concept of a dictionary, how old is that? Yeah, well, they, well, it's dictionaries that would be bilingual, say English into French, Latin, some other European language principally. They go back centuries into manuscripts, but as a printed work and a monolingual dictionary, 1604 tends to be cited as the first proper English dictionary, Robert Corddry's table

[00:12:02] or alphabetical table of difficult words. So just difficult ones, challenging ones, not, you know, not, not the all including. Pre-monored title, I love it. Yeah, it's great. And it didn't even have definitions in it. It was more what we call a thesaurus with synonyms. So, you know, fortunate might have something next to it as simple as lucky and that's it. Yeah. Move on. Effectively a guide to the written text, like legal text, scripture, with a much more sort

[00:12:30] of Anglo-Saxon word as its interpretation. So there's a real distinction between the written and the spoken word at that point. So that's, that's the early 17th century. So Shakespeare's still around, still walking around Fleet Street, performing around the corner, across the river. Playhouse yards as well. Exactly. And then, you know, over the course of a hundred or so years, the gap in the market appeared. Robert Dosley spotted there was quite a lot more money to be made.

[00:12:55] He's got an eye over to Europe, what's happening in the continent, various academies, institutions being established, France, Italy, Spain, the Netherlands, all doing that very 18th century thing of categorizing knowledge, classifying it. It starts with natural world, natural history, you know, Linnaeus and other applications of knowledge. And it starts to be applied to language. And yet it's not happening here, even though you've got this newly formed Great Britain,

[00:13:24] 1707, the Act of Unification. And you've got this sense of questioning who are we, what are we as a nation, a joint nation. There's lots of languages still within that nation. And if you go beyond England's boundaries and yet it's not happening. So Dosley, savvy businessman, spotted that market, knew there would be a demand, knew that what was there before was completely lacking in detail and were not all, you know, comparable

[00:13:52] to what was taking place across the continent. And entertaining, yeah. Especially from our perspective now. Yeah. A nice read. A nice read, yeah. And they just knew Johnson from other work that he'd done and knew him to be the best man for the job. He had that extraordinary capacity, pretty much, to recall everything he'd ever read. Wow. A total recall in a variety of languages. So, you know, he's walking around with what today would be a comprehensive database, which one would need to compile a dictionary today.

[00:14:20] He has it in his mind, that library. That's even more spooky, isn't it? It's an extraordinary capacity. I'm talking not just to another person, but another person and his genius. And his genius. He can remember everything I said. His brains. Speaking of which, discerning listeners will have noted that there was an interjection recently by the gentleman sitting on my right, who is not the ghost of our Australian absconder, but is our executive producer, Chris Wynn. I'm so glad you can be joining us. If you weren't here, we wouldn't have that box, would we? You would not. No, no.

[00:14:50] I am essential to the cause. You are essential. Essential. Essential. Essential. So here's a question for you. Do you think that Dr. Johnson was a spot the gap in the market type of guy, or do you think that he might have been more likely to say, the market hasn't had my dictionary, I don't care who's come before him? That's a difficult one to answer, but from everything I've read about him, he probably wasn't a guy to spot the market. He wasn't commercially minded, was he? No. No.

[00:15:19] In fact, he spent most of his life broke. Catastrophically and notoriously bad at financial management. Yeah, yeah. He was a writer through and through and trying to manage finances, trying to jump from one commission to another, which is why he was moving around so much. He had nearly 20 addresses whilst living in London across nearly 50 years because he's constantly unable to pay the rent anymore and having to move on. Pretty much. I mean, he does seem to get a bit better.

[00:15:45] There are some letters that survive between him and his publishers, and he's trying to negotiate, well, you know, for this copy, and if it goes into second edition, I want this amount of money. He gets a little better. He starts to speak the parlance of publishing, but he's just his own worst advocate, honestly. And then when he does receive money, just... Through his fingers. He spends it. Yeah, it's sand. Yeah. He spends it. He is charitable to a floor.

[00:16:13] You know, including anecdotes that exist that he was incapable of passing a street sleeper or somebody begging for assistance on the street without stopping to give him a penny, even if that's the last one he had. And he no longer could pop into the Cheshire Cheese for supper because he didn't have any supper money left. He sounds like a lovely guy, actually. He had lots of friends, didn't he? Yes. He was a great social... Incredibly sociable. Convivio is the word that he may have used himself.

[00:16:42] He was a complex man. Setting up the clubs, opening his house in Goff Square and later houses, too, to people who had nowhere else to go. Very, very empathetic and very socially engaged. But he was a complex man, so he could equally have periods in his life where he totally isolates himself. Again, to a fault. Totally isolates himself, cuts himself off from all other people. To write, or perhaps just in one of the spells of depression that he talks quite openly, writes quite openly about himself as well.

[00:17:12] So he could fluctuate. He was never just one thing or one person. He was incredibly benevolent, incredibly entertaining. I think you're right, a lovely, lovely person. But also, I think, fierce and acerbic in his criticism. And so I'm often asked in the museum, you know, this great hero, you'd obviously want to have dinner with him. And I was like, I'd be terrified of opening my mouth. Yeah. I mean, what could I say? Yeah. Any interest to a man of that nature. No.

[00:17:41] It's with the, I mean, I was just, I don't have to confess, I don't know much about him. And so I was doing a bit of reading, only like reading. But just this idea that people now think maybe he had some form of physical Tourette's with these tics. And I just, and now with what you're talking about as well as sort of sociability, I'm sort of picturing a sort of Slavoj Žižek type, you know, the Slovenian philosopher.

[00:18:05] Because he's got the tics and he's very gregarious and sort of charismatic, brings people in and known for his intellect as well. I'm sort of picturing someone, somewhat like that. Kind of like that, probably. Yes. That's an interesting comparison. That's it. That's an intelligent one. I'm trying to picture someone doing, in their day to day, I always try and do that with a lot of historical figures, picture their day to day.

[00:18:28] I feel like sometimes it's quite easy with historical figures to sort of cinematise them and picture them in a sort of grand reproduction of what they're doing. And actually I much prefer to picture them lighting the fire. Yes. Stacking the fire, wandering around. Yeah. Mundanity. Yeah. The human elements that unify us all. He'd probably be like that, but really scruffy. Really nice. Scruffy. Scruffy as well, to be fair. Notoriously scruffy.

[00:18:58] Yeah. Not known for personal hygiene, shall we say. That's, yeah. Geniuses are always scruffy. They're too busy. They're too busy. Minds on higher masses to bother brushing their teeth or changing their underpants. That's my excuse anyway. Me too. How would he have answered this question? Given your interest in the sodality of taverns and all the rest of it, and the fact that you've got the Cheshire Cheese with, I think there are six floors in this building. Oh, God, at least. Yes. Three or four rooms like this. So no shortage of space in which he could start a dinner club.

[00:19:27] So when he started the club down at Essex Head, it became, it's Edgar Wallace now, right? I think so, yeah. We've done a podcast down there with Katie Wignall, I think. Boy, my memory's not as bad as I thought it was. But anyway, why should he walk all the way down there to start a club when he's got this very clubbable place in the Cheshire Cheese? Well, that is, that's a great question. And I'm sure there are greater minds than me, pub historians and whatnot, who could answer that more sensibly. But I will give you my two pence worth, right?

[00:19:53] Which is, this was possibly not the most reputable of pubs at that time. At that time, naturally, not so now. It is a wonderful place to visit. Do come, bring your money. But it's definitely had some, so say, red district lights going on upstairs.

[00:20:16] And we know that because of the wonderful tiles that you are familiar with, Tam, that were discovered here some years ago during some renovations on one of the upper floors. Wasn't it tiles around the fireplace or something? Yes. I mean, saucy as hell. I mean, goodness, this is, you know, adult eyes only stuff. Was that something we were talking about? There was something, yeah, the porno tiles of Bleak Street, basically. Porno tiles. This is great. Are they still up, though? They are not.

[00:20:42] They're in the very sensible custodianship of the Museum of London, or London Museum, as it is to be reopening in a matter of days. Yeah. 28th of November. Now, there was an opportunity missed because we had Sharon Aiman on the podcast. In fact, she'll be publishing here on the 3rd of December. Oh, super. And we had a question to ask her, are you going to be using these tiles? Yes. We went around to see those tiles. Yes. And we told you there was an eagle war for someplace like that. Yeah, yeah, in the storage.

[00:21:09] And for obvious reasons, those tiles will never be displayed because they are quite explicit. Should we say, yeah. As only 13th century, was it? 13th? Yeah, 13th to 14th century. Wow. Oh, my God, I need to see these. Yeah, a rarity, but quite a treat, trust me. Yeah, it sounds amazing. Well, it's like those wonderful Norman carvings you find in churches around the outside of churches, which are very, yeah, very explicit. I made a Sheila McGoo pumpkin this year. I was very proud of her. Oh, that is impressive. The light shone through very well.

[00:21:38] I hope you've got lots of pictures of that. I have, I can say that. Excellent. I was very proud. She's still up, actually. We should probably throw her in the bin. Anyway, but yes. Would you call Johnson bawdy? Something like that. Oh, that's a good question. I mean, people were. I think no, by and large. I think he had capacity for slight humour here and there. Yeah. I really struggle to think of Johnson as anything other than asexual because that's just my, you know, conception. But that's not entirely true nor entirely fair. I mean, he was a red-blooded man after all.

[00:22:08] He adored his wife. He adored his wife. And there's images, if we're going to continue the low, you know, we've set the bar low now for what the conversation is. So now I've set the ground for that. There's David Grarrick, his dear, dear friend and, you know, star of the 18th century stage and whatnot, named still all over Covent Garden, was formerly a pupil of Johnson in one of those ill-fated attempts at him being a teacher before ever coming, either of them ever coming to London.

[00:22:36] And there's a little sketch that was recorded by Boswell, James Boswell, the biographer of Samuel Johnson, in which Garrick, as a young boy, a teen, was peeping through the keyhole of the Johnson's bedroom and could imitate Johnson in flagrante, basically. So there are... So body the parrot and victim Garrick. Exactly. And the tile. Between them. One and the same. Exactly. Fascinating gimmicks. So he was capable of being amorous on occasions.

[00:23:05] And the Garrick theme continues where there's a little sketch of Johnson going behind the scenes to visit Garrick when he's, you know, star of the Drury Lane Theatre. And then saying, actually, later, I'm not going to visit you behind the scenes any before because it excites my amorous propensities is what Boswell says.

[00:23:28] What Boswell has Johnson saying, but it's thought some clever, you know, researchers have the original, have seen the original text and it's something a lot more vulgar. Wow. Wow. About Garrick himself? No, no, this is Johnson talking about his genitals getting aroused when he pops behind and sees all the ladies getting dressed for their performing roles. Okay. But he's very self-censoring. He's a high moralist. I mean, there'll be Johnsonians aghast at what I've just said here.

[00:23:56] But, you know, he was a human being, was Johnson, although his mind was a lot. 99% of the time, he was prone to the flesh on occasions, I suppose. And that's one of them. So, yeah. But to answer your question, I've forgotten what it was now. Or was he bawdy? Was he bawdy? I think in conclusion, no. Which I mean in a nice way. In a bookie, entertaining way. One for blue jokes here and there.

[00:24:24] Being the scholar that he was, he wouldn't have made any claims about there being all of life in London without knowing what all of life might mean. Absolutely. This is true. He is the second most quoted person in the English language. He is, and I love you for knowing that. Is he after Shakespeare? After Shakespeare. I thought it would have been Oscar Wilde. Oscar Wilde does a lot of parodying or plagiarising of our dear beloved Johnson. We did talk about this. We did a wild one. And yes, he didn't make many of his up, whereas Johnson did. Yes. That's interesting. Johnson, the original Wilde.

[00:24:54] Yes. To rebrand him. So what are the classic examples then? Of Johnson? Oh, let's see. If we're thinking of Johnson and his wife, he famously said that marriage is the triumph of hope over experience. Oh, that was the Seattle. That was Oscar Wilde. Oh, well, I'm glad to rectify that today. Your mission is complete. Yes, exactly. I'll just sleep well. Yep, that's Johnson. And it should be noted that he only was ever married once.

[00:25:24] It was his wife for whom it was a second marriage. So maybe it's Teddy Johnson rather than Samuel that needs to be credited with that little insight. She was quite a lot older than him, wasn't she? Yes, yes. A good 20 plus year age gap. He was early 20. Like Shakespeare. My age really. 20 plus, but still an older woman. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. And she brought children with her?

[00:25:47] She had three children from her first marriage, yeah, who were never really reconciled to this ill match with this gangly, unemployed 20-something-year-old. So there isn't a happy ending there then? Well, no, I think there was. I think it was a love match on their part. No, no, I mean with regards to the children. With regards to the children, well, Lucy, the daughter, ended up being more amenable to reconciliation. She ended up living with Johnson's mother in Litchfield and taking care of her as she aged. Oh, sorry.

[00:26:14] So, and there's correspondence between Johnson and Lucy, which is quite affectionate. Johnson adored children. He never had any of his own. Mm-hmm. But there's these sort of proxies, these godchildren. There is, of course, above all else, Francis Barber, this little 10-year-old boy who came to live with him in extraordinary circumstances. Hi, this is Tam MacDonald, your host.

[00:26:35] If you're enjoying Timetable London, then please tell your friends about us by sending them a link to the show, giving us a mention on social media, or even by, or especially by, chatting about us in the pub. TimeTable London, for everything you love about the world's greatest city. Do tell us about Francis Barber from the plaques we were talking about earlier.

[00:27:01] Yes, we'll do interrupt because I'll start getting into sort of lecture mode at a certain point, which is dull for everybody concerned. But he was born in Jamaica on a sugarcane plantation. We know this mother, Grace, was taken from West Africa. We don't know specifically where. And taken into slavery. And he was born in Jamaica into slavery himself. Was he a mixed race? We don't honestly know. There is a question mark.

[00:27:29] Possibly he was the son of Bathurst, who was the plantation owner. Possibly not. Honestly, we won't ever know. And the only reason it's suggested that he may have been is because he was brought back to England with the Bathurst family, along with three other people, three other enslaved people, when Bathurst sold the plantation and with it, along with something between 150 and 200 people were sold with the plantation in the early 1750s.

[00:27:59] So that's how little Francis Barber arrives in England. He was given a birth name Quashane by his mother. It's a West African name that denotes a boy born on a Sunday. I forgive my butchering of the pronunciation, I'm sure there. So he came over as an eight-year-old boy from Jamaica's warm tropical climes to cold England.

[00:28:23] Now, the son of the plantation owner had grown up, no doubt, witnessing the horrors of how people were treated by his own father, in fact. And he was anti-slavery. He did not believe that it should take place. He was a religious clergyman in the Church of England. And he was friends with Samuel Johnson. So if we flash forward a little bit, Johnson's been living, working on the dictionary, living in Goff Square for a while now. And his beloved wife, Teddy, passes away.

[00:28:49] And he's utterly distraught, inconsolable in his grief, locks the house up, locks himself away, won't receive visitors, isn't going out. And his mental health, but his physical health very much, is deteriorating quickly. There's no food to eat. So it's thought that in a bid to try and liberate Francis Barber from the household of this slave-owning person, we believe they own Barber, into the household of somebody who desperately needed some form of assistance, because Johnson didn't have staff, didn't have children.

[00:29:20] Richard sent Barber around to Goth Square, to Samuel Johnson's house. And he's only 10 years old. And it's important to remember, he's got no agency in this. So he's just told, you live here, and now you live here. And he crosses the threshold of 17 Goth Square in 1752 to a house that's rather large, full with this man drowning in his own grief,

[00:29:43] with all of his peculiarities as well, and struggles with mental health, as we would term it today. And sort of is told to sort of crack on in this household. And Johnson doesn't know what to do with a servant. He's never had one before. He didn't grow up with them, didn't have them in his marriage. He doesn't know what to do with a child. Again, didn't grow up with them.

[00:30:02] So he effectively starts to educate Barber, who's a very bright young boy, reading, writing English, but Latin and Greek and other languages too. He gives them some very light duties, like pop to the market for some food and some firewood, that kind of thing. And importantly, Barber has his own agency to choose to work elsewhere, which he does do when he's about 14 years old. He inherits a bit of money when Bathurst, the plantation owner, dies.

[00:30:31] This does sound like there must have been some sort of... There was a trigger for it, yes. So he gets some money, and he's told in that will that he's been left his freedom. Now, Samuel Johnson vehemently anti-slavery. He's long argued that no person is the property of another. It's an inconceivable state, which is why Richard had sent Francis Barber to him, somebody who'd treat him far better. Can I interject a question there? Yes, please do. I'm going on. Well, it's great. He's only 10 years old. He's a lot more.

[00:31:01] It struck me when I heard you speaking at the Barber Pluck evening, the other evening, that perhaps we undervalue the extent to which you've got to be a pretty brave human being to speak out against slavery at the time and in the place that he did. Unless he was... I can't imagine that Dr. Johnson would be the sort of person that... He says it because he doesn't care what people think. He says it because it's right, and he seems to be almost unconsciously magnanimous about this little tyke who's turned up in his doorstep.

[00:31:31] Well, I think Johnson is a person that would not be dictated to by anybody, and he would say what he truly believed, but he only formed his opinion through seriously broad reading and contemplation. Think before you speak. Think. He's a perfect model of that, I think. And so he had a very strong moral compass. He was quite a moralist in many ways and took his Anglican faith very seriously. It was guided by that sense of hierarchy and structure in society as well.

[00:32:02] But, yes, he wouldn't really consider his words for the reception, for their reception. He would say, this is what I think and why. And he definitely thought, he just found it inconceivable. I agree. How can one person believe that they own another human being? Right. And there is no example of it anywhere in the animal species either. No. You don't see that in forced indenture among species. You might have a hierarchy in alpha and other, but...

[00:32:32] What is it called? Not altruism. Symbiosis. Yes, symbiosis. So you get those little... It benefits them both. Yeah. The little fish that will fly and, you know, swim into the teeth and the mouth of a shark to clean the teeth. That sort of thing. The side of sharks. That sort of thing exists. That's really interesting to think about. Yeah. It hasn't ever been documented in eight, I'm guessing. No. No. Strict social hierarchy. Yes. Yeah. So having an alpha seems critical to, you know, communal living, effectively. Yeah. But, yeah.

[00:33:01] You see it in canines as well, but... Yeah. Okay, so... There we are. I digress. We're still some way from where we got to in the end, whereby Francis Barber actually inherits much of what Johnson is behind. Yes, yes. So we zip through most of Barber's life. You know, he goes off to Cheapside to study apothecaries. He joins the Navy for a while. Comes back, gets married. Has children of his own. Always living with Johnson. This is the real speed it up version now. And when... He's there when Johnson dies.

[00:33:28] By his bedside, you know, 32 years after they first met and lived together. And he's named as his sole heir. So it's not that Johnson has a huge amount to give, but through the sale of his library, which is the only thing of value he does own, Barber inherits about 1,500 guineas, which is just by pure coincidence the same amount of money Johnson had been paid back in 1746 to write the bloody dictionary in the first place.

[00:33:55] What is the value of Johnson's library at the end in contemporary terms? Yes, ooh, around 1,500 guineas. It was 1,500 guineas then, which today would be worth what? Oh, I don't like questions like that, Tam. They're really hard because, you know, you could use the rates of inflation, which I find slightly arbitrary. They're not factually inaccurate, but just a little more than a pound. It's a pound and a shilling or something. Yeah, okay.

[00:34:24] So, I mean, a lot of money. It's a significant amount of money. I like to do it sort of relatively. I think relative value has greater sense. So renting Goff Square in the middle of the 18th century costs 30 pounds a year. Right. So 1,500 is a lot of money. Yeah, for sure. Certainly for a servant, let alone a servant who had been born into slavery. And there were some very non-enlightened friends of Johnson, even one of the executives of the will, a rather unpopular John Hawkins.

[00:34:52] Unpopular to history, I should say. Who almost tried to, well, not fulfill Johnson's wishes. But anyway, there were others like Joshua Reynolds who absolutely insisted Francis should get what he was left. So he did. Was this Hawkins chap just being generally bullshit or was he having it in for Francis Barber? Oh, well, he wasn't. He was pretty racist and unpleasant character. I mean, he had other attributes.

[00:35:19] Like he was a great source of consolation to Johnson in his spiritual needs. So, you know, he has his place in Johnson's life, but he was not somebody I would want a cup of tea with. Oh, for sure. Yeah. So anyway, Johnson Barber gets his money and goes off to Litchfield, which is something Johnson had encouraged that he do. There'd be a warm reception, Johnson's own network, extended friends and whatnot up there. It's a small town, significant and very interesting one to visit.

[00:35:49] And he sets up a school. So he's a first black school with the money. Yeah. Yeah. So extraordinary life. Was he more successful than Johnson being a teacher? How does one qualify what makes a good teacher? Was he the schoolmaster? Was he the headmaster? Or did he all... Yeah, again, this is unpicking some really important questions. What qualifies even as a school? So it wasn't a full-blown grammar school, but it was more than a Dane school, which is basically daycare for infants.

[00:36:17] It was something in the middle in a sort of provincial place. But it didn't really thrive, sadly. Again, people perhaps less inclined to send their children to a person of African descent at that time. This is late 18th century by this time. Just wanting to impart his knowledge. I know, I know. And he'd be so intelligent. But following his death in 1801, his wife and daughter continued what would become more of a Dane school.

[00:36:48] Dane school. Dane school. I've heard of that. Yeah, so they're sort of, you know, your latter-day nurseries in some ways, or early years centres. So the line did continue. The line did continue. And your plaque unveiling the other evening, there were some descendants there? Yes. Or there were supposed to be? Yes, so we do get visited. Barbara had children. He had three children. One died in infancy with two adults. And named Samuel. Actually, his two boys were named Samuel and a daughter.

[00:37:15] And there is a direct lineage where we're in close contact with Barbara's, sorry, Johnson on the brain. Barbara's eighth generation descendant. A lovely man called Cedric Barber and his family. But the iterations go on. So we sometimes just get Barbers popping in. I was delighted just last week to see John Barber had signed the visitor guest. But I hadn't been around or he didn't declare that he was there. It was like so wonderful to come to the home of my ancestor. Yeah. I've had that with them.

[00:37:42] I did some research on the Toll Puddle Martyrs for my masters and went to the church and the visitor's book. There were so many descendants of, well, at least three of the men coming in. You could see they had the same surname, following in the footsteps of my ancestors. And doing pilgrimage as well. So this is why, you know, these historic buildings like the church, like the house, like the pub here, you know, they are really important. Oh my God. Don't get me stoned. Yeah.

[00:38:10] Tam, do you remember the wonderful manager of this pub a number of years ago? And he had kept, he was really interested in the history and kind of safeguarding some of its archives. And the visitor book. The all-important visitor book. There was a visitor book. There was a visitor book. Oh, yes. Well, very well remembered. I've got a quick story for you. And we should say something about this marvelous pub beyond the obvious thing about Dickens and Johnson. But you're quite right. Did you hear about the, well, the parrot had pecked away at quite a few of these.

[00:38:39] There were about, I think, 10 or 12. Is nobody feeding the bulldog? Probably not. And the two things that we noted, the manager then gave one of our colleagues and me an afternoon up on the sixth floor looking through these red books. And the two things about the red books that really stood out were that most of them were pecked at. Most of the pages were pecked at. That's great. And a lot of the pages had been taken by people who said, well, I'll just have that William Burke signature. Yeah. Yeah. Signature hunters, autograph collectors.

[00:39:09] But the one thing we found that perhaps had been lost to history because people didn't appreciate exactly what they were looking at, which is very often, I think, a factor in libraries and museums. The ephemera. Yeah. Yeah. But there was one page in there that was signed off by all the people who came to the last dinner at the Cheshire Cheese before they went down, got on their boat and sailed off to the Falklands. Oh. And it was the senior management of whatever they're called, of HMS Sheffield. Really?

[00:39:37] So that's the ship that went down. And their last meal was here, upstairs here. Wow. So there's value in them, their archives. Yeah. Even post-pecking. Yeah. Even post-pecking. We had that with the pub in my local village, Queen's Head in Burley. I found out not that long ago that Glenn Miller of the Glenn Miller Orchestra, supposedly his last meal before he went AWOL. Oh, not AWOL. Boss, you see? Yeah. Well, yeah. Whatever. What a fascinating story that is, isn't it? He was flying, I think.

[00:40:07] He was part of the area. Yeah. I thought he was in. The flame just disappeared. Is that what it was? Yeah. So supposedly his last meal was at Queen's Head in Burley. Apparently. It was one of the last places he was seen before he went missing. Wow. So yeah, no, these are, I mean, I don't know where the, there's no maybe, I mean, it's just one of those things that's passed along. I don't know if there's any written stuff like that. But yeah, what you've just described is the reason that I collect sort of quite mundane aspects of my life. You never know.

[00:40:34] Let's go up to this pub and play Serenade in Blue and see if it makes the four boards creak. Yeah. I mean, there's so much folklore about that pub that there was a cellar down below. Supposedly they were doing renovations. Because it was a smuggler's route, my village back in the day. And there was a smuggler's family there. And supposedly they opened up the cellar and there were these doubloons and a treasure trove and rum and port and things like that. But there's no, everyone always says this.

[00:41:01] And I don't know when the renovations took place or, you know, but no one's ever been allowed down to see it or, you know, any of this. Whereas actually this place does have a tangible archive or so to speak. So, yeah, I do love it. And apparently the guy who invented the lava lamp did so because he was inspired by one of the kitchen guys at the Queen's Head. He had an egg timer that used oil or something. Oh, OK. And so we can all thank the Queen's Head and Burley for the invention of the lava lamp. I didn't know that. I honestly love it. It's such a funny pub.

[00:41:30] It's got all these crazy stories. I love my lava lamp as a teen girl. Same. I was part of the noughties revival of lava lamps. I had like two, I think. So where are the archives here? Are they kept here? Yeah. Yeah, I think there's a deal of ephemera on the site still. The real serious stuff has gone off to the London Museum archives. Oh, right. So we may be able to see that. Yeah. It's insane. It's always worth asking. Fine.

[00:41:56] Well, back in that day, there were a number of these big red books that obviously made a fuss over it because these things were massive, huge signature books and they were under lock and key up in a room halfway up. And how long ago was that then that you saw them off? Four or five years. It's not that long now. OK. Yeah. It stresses me out the idea of these things not just being either, you know, management changes and they, you know. Well, this, this, yeah, you're subject to the custodians and their interests, their interest

[00:42:26] in history, their understanding of really we're all just custodians of these places and these objects. We come and go. They should stay. One of the less noble aspects of our species, hey, that there are good moral agents among us, but there are a few not so good ones. Yeah. And the impulse to go in and trash the place and take your own souvenirs. Yes. It's a souvenir collection. Yeah. In all the rest. What would, what would Dr. Johnson have made of the, the current appetite for memorializing things and so on? Because museums weren't a thing in that day, were they?

[00:42:55] Well, you do have the British Museum opening whilst he's writing away his dictionary. Antiquaries, yes. The Society of Antiquaries is being established. There's a sense of preservation and conservation and record keeping. You've got to love a record in the 18th century. Categorizing knowledge and things. I think in principle, happy that monuments, certainly edifices, you know, really significant buildings, you know, your path and then let's say, are being preserved.

[00:43:23] He possibly, this is just my opinion, you know, I don't want to ever speak for Johnson, possibly would have more qualms or more reservations about immortalizing an individual. Right. Right. Yes. Or their character, their personality. Yeah. So, I mean, he, and I only really think this because he writes a lot about other poets, poets that he absolutely admires beyond compare, your Shakespeare, Milton Cowley, Abraham Cowley,

[00:43:53] possibly arguably his favorite. But he will write their biographies. Towards the end of his life, it's the last major work that he does. 52 biographies of English poets. And they basically descend into a whole load of literary criticism about their work, but there are biographical details in there too. Talk about a guy who suffers from a mission creep. My God. Not in his dictionary, but something definitely written into his dictionary with blood, sweat and tears.

[00:44:19] He does talk about them and he, you know, criticizes personality traits. So John Milton, one of the greatest, you know, no poet soared as high. Yeah, he was absolutely rotter. He was a Republican, dastardly Republican and treated more broadly women in his life horribly. His wife, his daughters, he was known as being a tyrant at home and a brute.

[00:44:42] So he could separate art and artists, I think, in a way that is actually quite a topical conversation in the 21st century in cancel culture. In the last couple of days. We're going to focus on authors and the consequences of behaviour and people in mainstream media and whatnot. So death of the author is not a term bandied around by him, but it's an interesting question. He would have been very fascinated by the concept. He would have. He'd had a lot to say about it.

[00:45:11] Oh, that's a wonderful what could have been, isn't it? The idea of him considering the death of the author as a concept, debating it. But, yeah. He would have made a good dinner companion, actually. Oh, yeah. Yeah. So once you've got over the sort of the awe. The data collection of people's dinner table guests. You know, everyone has their dream dinner table. How often he features. Oh, probably a lot. Like how often he's quoted. Yeah. Yeah. But you said he was religious into Anglicanism.

[00:45:40] Was there a church you went to in particular? Great question. Yes. So he did favour St. Dunstan's. No, sorry. He did attend St. Dunstan's in the West. That's where Francis Barber got married, coincidentally. But St. Clement Danes. Oh, right. Yes. St. Clement Danes. St. Paul's. So that's one of the island churches along the Strand. There's St. Mary's Strand and St. Clement Danes. Clement Danes is the one with the statue at the back. The statue stands there at the back. Yeah. It's now the RAF Church.

[00:46:09] It was very heavily bombed in the 1940s, I think. But yeah, it's a beautiful place. Does he have his own bench there? He does have his own bench there, yes. Oh, well, that's fantastic. Yes. I wasn't expecting you to say yes. Oh, yes. Oh, that's wonderful. Yes. Let's go and see that. And is that an Oranges and Lemons church? It is the Oranges and Lemons church. I won't sing it for you because you'll lose all of your listeners immediately tuning out. Oh, well, there you go. Come on now. It's a delicate machine. Yeah. Wow.

[00:46:39] But yeah, that's fascinating. I'll have to look at more of the City of London churches. As they're some of the best medieval churches in the city as well. Yeah. For sure. Beautiful. One of the things about these dinner lists you see when somebody says, who would your sixth be and so on, it always strikes me when I read those things that these people might be incredibly relevant and attractive to you. Yeah. But without necessarily being very attractive to each other. Yes. So I wonder... That makes a good dinner party.

[00:47:08] I don't think Eleanor McHartane and Nina Simone would have had to be a bit chaotic. Possibly. But imagine a dinner party with Dr. Johnson and David Hume at the same table. Because there's not much evidence of them coming into each other's orbit. It's almost like they were two great mastiffs walking through 18th century society and hugely respectful of one another. Yeah. But they didn't have much to do with each other, did they?

[00:47:36] Oh, now you've got me. I don't believe so and I don't know so. So that's not to say a great time I could answer with more detail than that. But interesting. I mean, I think like many people, like a good dinner guest per se, you want to get to the root of the mast. So even if you're debating, as long as it's respectful, as long as it's not an ad hominem attack and you don't attack the person, you just challenge the ideas to get to the root of the truth, then it's a great conversation.

[00:48:06] And that's going back to Johnson, obviously my favourite guy. It makes it hard to answer questions like, what did he think about this? What did he? Because a lot of the time, well, definitely not, right? So definitely not, what? Don't want to speak for somebody, especially somebody who's dead, posthumous, they can't defend themselves or correct you. But more importantly, in terms of citation, he could write or be quoted saying one thing in debate, but he's arguing the matter. And he could easily take either side.

[00:48:34] And what he personally thinks is actually almost irrelevant. Yeah. He loves the debate and the art of oracy and rhetoric. So you can defend that with sheer logic to the root, to the point where you either agree or disagree or agree to disagree, but hopefully change your opponent's mind and you've won basically the rhetoric challenge. But he could be quoted saying contradictory things. Well, that again is a sign of genius, isn't it, actually? Because you can see both sides of the argument. Exactly.

[00:49:04] And you can argue yourself round in circles. You can, yeah. I mean, that's part of the full process, isn't it? Rationalising to argue with yourself. If you read some of his essays, if anybody ever is interested in a bit of a mental workout, right? Read some of Johnson's essays. They'll take you 10 minutes, 1,500 words long. They're all available online for free or you can buy them in Dr. Johnson's gift shop. Fabulous. Oh, excellent. But yeah, I recommend that to anybody because you will see that. I would like to read that, actually. The shape of his arguments. It helps you. I think it improves how you think. Yeah.

[00:49:34] Yeah. Yourself. Very much so. I think I've heard that said of Addison and Steele as well. The great prose writers of the early 18th century. Yeah, yeah. Get the essays. You get the thought coming out and you wonder, could people do that long form thinking and writing nowadays, especially given the number of times they've got to jump into the phone? Well, if you read Cinema Year Zero, the slow criticism film journal, you'll see some of that in the film. Sorry, I'm plugging my... Oh, interesting. No, please tell us more. Just plugging my film journal.

[00:50:01] It's part of our ethos is the idea of slow criticism because film criticism nowadays is either essentially promoting the film or being an influencer for it or it's sort of written in quite short form. So our whole thing is taking several weeks, if not months, to get the written drafts in, edit them in three parts and publish them. As writing has been for much of the written word. Exactly. Yes. As people used to do it. Yeah. Between 800 and...

[00:50:30] Well, actually between 800 and 2,000 words. But yeah. And where can you find them? It's online. It's cinemayearzero.com. Yes. And it also... We apparently are now selling it in a used zine bookshop in Peckham. So you can be found... Wow. Well, I'd love to find out. You can be found out there. But no, it is happening, but I think in very small... I mean, the public domain website, they do wonderful long reads about, well, stuff in

[00:51:00] the public domain. Yes. Substack seems to be a good place for... Yeah. Substack is actually really good for that. It's very full. Yeah. Substack's very full. If you filter out the dross, there's some really good stuff there. Like semiearzero.com. You're like that. Sorry, I'll stop plugging in. No, you're right, though. It's not really seen as something to prioritise, maybe, in written word now. Or even just a physical skill.

[00:51:25] The amount of times I hear from academics that there is absolutely no way a student, probably even anybody under the age of 30, could sit and write a three-hour exam physically. Like their wrist wouldn't be up. The reason I studied... Let alone any sort of mental capacity. It's a physiological barrier now. The reason I studied drama was that when I went to the open day, they said, you'll never have to do a written exam ever again.

[00:51:52] And I was like, fantastic, sign me up right now. Yeah, no, the sort of muscles it requires. A three-hour exam. A brutal. Just writing. It's an endurance test more than an intellectual one, perhaps. But yeah, forming ideas is an interesting one. The idea of how to think, how to express thought is... With the rise of, you know, before we even discuss the can of worms that is AI and what direction that might be heading in, you've just got the copy and paste and the ease with

[00:52:19] which you can live edits, I suppose, in a way that if you're writing, like many of the writers who's passed through the old Cheshire Cheese and along Fleet Street, would just have a turkey feather to hand. Yeah. Yeah. You know, you really have to think before you speak, because it costs you money to write. It really does. Yes. You know, there's ink, paper, feathers. There's the whole economy behind thought at this time as well. It doesn't really get considered often, I don't think.

[00:52:48] Well, if there's a compromise, something of a compromise between long-form thinking and tick-tockery, maybe it's a really interesting pub conversation. There we go. Of the sort that we've had today. I was going to say thank you very much, even with the plugging. It's been fascinating hearing... Sorry. ...never missing opportunities to plug. Exactly. But that's all part of the fun. And on that note, do visit Dr. Johnson's house, 17 Goff Square, just off Fleet Street. I was just about to ask you to do that, but you jumped in and did it. Of course I did.

[00:53:18] I wouldn't be doing my job properly if not. So, Dean, thank you very much for joining us today. My pleasure entirely. I think that we've got to make sure that we don't leave it another four years before we do our next podcast. Definitely. Right. It's so easy to get down here. 129 steps. 129 steps, no less. There we go. And thanks to Chris for helping us along. Pleasure. Absolutely. Thanks to the old church. And to you.

[00:53:43] Do join us again next time when we will be meeting Sharon Amon, Director of the London Museum, opening in Smithfield on November 28th. There will be plenty to talk about, including Sharon's vision looking ahead to an exciting future for the museum. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.